Youth and the Media: Is it really just child’s play?

The portrayal of children in the media and its impact upon young people has been a hot debate in the mediated public sphere for as long as it has been occurring. Whether its a book, film, tv show or video game, any text in the media that portrays young people or is watched and enjoyed by youth can have a profound impact on their ‘looking-glass self’ (Cooley, 1902: pp 152), their behaviour and their understanding of what is ethically right and wrong.

To begin, there is the oh so infamous case of Ms Miley Cyrus. Teenage Disney star turned whatever you’d prefer to call her now, Miley may have lost a lot in the way of respect and dignity but there is no denying her all-time high level of influence on her youthful audience because of the music video for her most recent single, Wrecking Ball (2013). As comical as it may seem, the effects of this music video on young people is far spread and indisputable. One simply has to look at Michigan’s Grand Valley State University in Michigan, USA for proof, where the 40 year old sculpture of a wrecking ball created by artist Dale Eldred (1973) was removed in 2013 for safety purposes following over 200 incidents of university students parodying the music video by stripping naked and mounting the statue whilst being filmed by peers (McKay, 2013).

The second case study I’m going to look at is that of the Chucky horror series, and in particular Child’s Play 3: Look Who’s Stalking, which has been plagued by accusations of inciting violence in children and as the direct “inspiration” for two murders, that of Suzanne Capper in December 1992 and James Bulger in February 1993. In the Suzanne Capper case, the 16-year-old was held prisoner for a week, brutally tortured and then set on fire and left to die by teenager Bernadette McNeilly. Throughout this time McNeilly “assumed the character of Chucky” by mimicking certain violent scenes from the film and continuously repeating the phrase “I’m Chucky, wanna play?” whilst torturing Capper. After McNeilly admitted in court to having repetitively watched several films from the Chucky series as a young child, one lawyer from the prosecution stated in an interview, “if you asked me whether this material in these minds had some effect on what happened, I would have to say yes” (Foster, 1993).

Despite the fact that it is impossible to ethically prove the link between the media and its effects on young people, the evidence is all there. No, watching a film or music video is not going to make every kid re-enact the scenes in those texts. But it would be heedless to say that the chances of a young person committing these acts before watching these texts were not lower than they were after watching them. I’m not suggesting that children should be completely protected from these subjects, because most kids know about these subjects from quite young ages and turn out just fine (myself included). But I do believe that the media should take this issue seriously because children’s over-exposure to certain subjects can have very real consequences and not every young person who views this content is going to turn out ‘just fine’. Take this video as another example, do you think what these children are doing is ok?

(On a quick side note, these effects can also be hilarious!)

Reference List:
1. Cooley, C.H. (1902), Human Nature and the Social Order, Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York, pp 152
2. Cyrus, M (2013), ‘Wrecking Ball’, in Bangerz, RCA, New York City
3. Eldred, D (1973), Untitled, Spencer Gallery of Art, Michigan
4. McKay, H (2013), GVSU forced to remove campus wrecking ball sculpture due to Miley Cyrus parodies, Fox News, New York City
5. Foster, J (1993), Horror fiction became reality, The Independent, London
6. Torres, A (2012), I’m Sexy & I Know It: Kid Parody,
7. Kardnyal, S (2013), Miley Cyrus – Wrecking Ball (Chatroulette Version),

About Tom Fogarty

I'm 20 years old. I live on the South Coast. I'm currently studying a double degree in Media and Communications at UOW. I'm in a hardcore band called Pariah. Thats about it, as far as I know anyway. View all posts by Tom Fogarty

5 responses to “Youth and the Media: Is it really just child’s play?

  • Sloth of Space

    I agree that Cyrus becoming what she is now was a BIG shift from disney to twerk but as a 21 year old who’s original audience is just as old it also begs the question of when is too soon to leave hannah montana behind?

    • tomfogarty95

      Yeah she was always going to have to do something dramatic and controversial evolve from ‘child-star’ to ‘mature artist’ at some point, just like almost every child-star before her, so I guess it was inevitable. But it certainly did divide a lot of people, fans or not!

  • haroldjohnpador

    I can not appreciate how strong your arguement is. So many well discussed sources, so well clarified, and the choice of theme is so prominate and obvious to you it seems as if you can go for days and days about youth in the media, not to mention how you maintained such an interesting style of writing with videos.

    How ever, what made you choose your sources? I couldn’t help but notice you chose sources that features ‘youth’ but are not at all related or directed to youth. Its a tricky aspect to approach but, like the ideas of corporate pedophilia, of course those sources aren’t intended for children.

    To support you however, I remember how cheeky Zach Effrons 17 again was, that movie was PG and had a core market for teens and tweens and if i recall correctly and contained some real, adult orientated subject matter.

    • tomfogarty95

      Thank you for your comments! I actually went into this blog with the complete opposite viewpoint because I just couldn’t stand the conservative idea that ‘violent video games make kids violent’, but then at some point I looked at what I’d written and realised that I was arguing for the opposite side and by the end of the blog my whole view of the issue had changed.

      I guess I’m just not interested in any texts that position children at the centre of their focus either within the actual text or as their audience, so I found it just much easier to write about texts that are simply viewed by young people.

      Ahh yes I do remember 17 Again! I can’t remember exactly how old I was at the time I first saw it but I do remember thinking Zac Efron was the coolest guy ever in those jeans, white shirt, leather jacket and aviators. It certainly had a few sneaky and not-so-sneaky sexual and drug references in there though!

  • samdoesuow

    I thought this post was great, you write very well and I commend you for using several criminal cases as examples, also the use of youtube links works very well.

    My only criticism is that I find it ends a tad too abruptly, but that may just be nit-picky

    Great work though, Sam

Leave a Reply to Sloth of Space Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: