Can we blame the media for Australia’s attitude towards asylum seekers?

‘Asylum seekers’ – the two words that seem to have become their own cliche in modern Australian news and media. An issue that, according to a study by refugee advocate Professor Andrew Markus, is viewed by the general population as the second most significant issue in Australia behind economics (2007). An issue that has divided society to the point where 45% of Australians admit that they would be uncomfortable interacting with a refugee, 51% of Australians believe in negative stereotypes of asylum seekers relative to those they perceived as ‘native white Australians’ and 36% think that asylum seekers pose a threat to Australia’s resources and society (Nickerson, 2004).

So who is to blame for this? The government? With campaign slogans such as Tony Abbott’s Liberal Party’s “Stop the boats” and Kevin Rudd’s Labor Party’s promotion of the method of offshore processing that could seem very justified. What about the media? Well without the media campaigns such as Tony Abbott’s and Kevin Rudd’s never would have reached the living rooms of Australian homes as effectively as they did, and without the media I would not be turning on the tv of a night to be regularly greeted by the sight of scared, dirty and impoverished “boat people” seen to be attempting to ‘jump the queue’ and ‘cheat the system’ by getting on boats and illegally arriving in Australia, a representation that I believe has in fact facilitated the view held by 71% of Australians that we are not guilty of mistreating people who apparently are already trying to cheat us (Nickerson, 2004).

However, is the media entirely to blame for this, or is there also a cultural aspect to this issue? If we look back at Australia’s history and the dehumanisation of Aboriginal people that has occurred since the arrival of the First Fleet, the persecution of Chinese gold miners during the 1850s, the abuse of South Sea Islander ‘kanakas’ who worked in the banana plantations of Northern Queensland throughout the late 19th century, the White Australia Policy that was active throughout the early-mid 20th century, former Australian Prime Minister John Curtin’s statement during the Second World War, “this country shall remain forever the home of the descendants of those people who came here in peace in order to establish in the South Seas an outpost of the British race” (Department of Immigration and Border Protection, 2012) and the current explosion of the ‘We can make it tougher’ competition between the Liberal and Labor parties in relation to federal policy concerning the treatment of asylum seekers, we can come to the conclusion that the despite the wrongdoing of much of the Australian media in its overtly conservative and racist portrayal of asylum seekers, the real issue of racial discrimination and intolerance, xenophobia and ethnocentrism is embedded in Australia’s very culture.

However, despite the fact that the issue itself may not be entirely a result of the media, I do believe that the media and government’s blatant dehumanisation and demonisation of asylum seekers and their facilitation of a national attitude that Human Rights Watch has dubbed “extremely harsh and egregious” (Millar, 2014) towards these people does justify the blame that they do receive from many Australian and international citizens and organisations.

Reference List:
1. Markus, A (2007), Asylum seekers and social cohesion, SBS World News, Melbourne
2. Nickerson, A (2004), Australians’ Attitudes to Asylum Seekers, University of Queensland Press, Brisbane
3. Department of Immigration and Border Protection (2012), Fact Sheet 8: Abolition of ‘White Australia’ Policy, Canberra
4. Millar, L (2014), Human Rights Watch annual report says Australia’s record damaged by treatment of asylum seekers, Australian Broadcasting Company, Ultimo
5. Jones, G, McPhedran, I (2012), Malaysia set to trade asylum seekers in detention centre deal with Australia, Herald Sun, Southbank



About Tom Fogarty

I'm 20 years old. I live on the South Coast. I'm currently studying a double degree in Media and Communications at UOW. I'm in a hardcore band called Pariah. Thats about it, as far as I know anyway. View all posts by Tom Fogarty

3 responses to “Can we blame the media for Australia’s attitude towards asylum seekers?

  • chantellemayo

    I found your post questioning the media’s role in the dehumanisation of asylum seekers in Australia very interesting, as it made me question many of the views I hear people expressing around me about the intentions of people who are attempting to make a new life in Australia after escaping often atrocious living conditions in their native countries. Your use of statistics is what made the biggest impact, as the specificity of them forced me to acknowledge what really is happening to these people, and to understand the attitudes of the majority of Australia people towards them. I was also very impressed with your evaluation that these created perceptions cannot necessarily be blamed completely on the media, though I believe it does play a very large role due to it’s huge power of the ideas and perceptions held by the general population of, in this case, Australia, and wholeheartedly agree that much of the issue derives from Australian culture.

  • rubencampbell

    I am impressed with this article you gave some valid points and you had plenty of statistical evidence to back up your point. But apart from the media being blamed or this I think the problem with the asylum seeker issue is that politics has too much influence. For example before the liberal party lost election in 2007 in that year 148 people arrived by boat. Then when the Labor Government the number of people arriving by boat increased each year and in 2013 a total of 20 587 people arrived by boat. I believe the decision should be a bipartisan between the two main federal parties and it should be a decision that is made that not put the lives of refugees at risk

  • adamursino

    I’m really passionate about how asylum seekers are being grossly misrepresented by all different forms of media in Australia so this post is really interesting. Australia receives less asylum seeker arrivals by boat than many other countries like the US and England, we’ve got a smaller population density, but we still make a much bigger fuss about it. Even though it’d be folly to blame the media entirely, you’re right in saying that the media does influence views in a very negative way. It ultimately boils down to how it’s a cultural thing: Australia is somewhat xenophobic. Nonetheless, one of the things that I would have liked to see is discussion of the fact that we do all have the ability to think critically and deconstructing the messages we receive from the media regarding asylum seekers is probably a good start in terms of dispelling the dodgy treatment of “boat people” in the media. Nice post!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: